Bringing you the "Good News" of Jesus Christ and His Church While PROMOTING CATHOLIC Apologetic Support groups loyal to the Holy Father and Church's magisterium
Home About
AskACatholic.com
What's New? Resources The Church Family Life Mass and
Adoration
Ask A Catholic
Knowledge base
AskACatholic Disclaimer
Search the
AskACatholic Database
Donate and
Support our work
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
New Questions
Cool Catholic Videos
About Saints
Disciplines and Practices for distinct Church seasons
Purgatory and Indulgences
About the Holy Mass
About Mary
Searching and Confused
Contemplating becoming a Catholic or Coming home
Homosexual and Gender Issues
Life, Dating, and Family
No Salvation Outside the Church
Sacred Scripture
non-Catholic Cults
Justification and Salvation
The Pope and Papacy
The Sacraments
Relationships and Marriage situations
Specific people, organizations and events
back
Doctrine and Teachings
Specific Practices
Church Internals
Church History


Jeffrey Caperton wrote:

Hi, guys —

In recent months, I cannot help but notice on Catholic Forums the battle over economic models:

  • Capitalism versus Socialism
  • Keynesian economics versus Supply-side economics
  • Big government versus Big business
  • Income distribution versus Wealth accumulation
  • ad nauseam!

What I cannot help but notice is that those who favor Capitalism, free markets, supply-side economics, etc. tend to be more adamant, with some actually quite hostile towards those who do not fully agree with their point of view, while this is also true of those on the left sometimes.

While generally apolitical and skeptical of both sides (I do not believe a just society is possible through either model), I cannot help but notice that American Christians tend to favor Capitalism and even some Catechisms come down more in favor of the capitalist model touting that Capitalism is more conducive to freedom.

My problem with Capitalism is the focus is upon consumerism and self-interest, both of which are a hindrance to Christ's message of faith (Remember the sixth chapter of Matthew, consider the lilies of the field (Matthew 6:25-30) and self-denial. However, many do not really regard the teachings of the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5-7) as relevant to the real world, so I will focus upon the concept that Capitalism is more conducive to freedom.

I find that consumerism and self-interest are just as enslaving to the individual as any totalitarian state. I would go so far as to offer that Christians, in a third world countries, are just as free as Christians in the United States; perhaps even more so. Consider the drudgery with which we engage daily on jobs that often ask us to compromise our personal values, just to get ahead. Then consider the millions (or billions?) we spend on marketing to convince consumers just how incomplete their lives will be unless they purchase the product being advertised.

  • the status that comes with the ownership of a BMW
  • how a diamond tells her that we truly love her
  • the importance to our cool kids to wear these jeans

Quite frankly, we are slaves to our lifestyles. Finally, consider that the freedom Christ spoke of has nothing to do with the freedom of the free market.

Personally, I find Capitalism just another form of Darwinism. I have often said that if Americans ever discover that God is not a Capitalist, the United States will become a Buddhist country.
I was once chastised by a priest who told me that growth as a person and Christian was not possible without ownership of property. I never thought to remind him of St. Francis and
St. Clare of Assisi, or the many others throughout history who renounced worldly goods and reached an ultimate growth as a person and a Christian.

You are probably wondering if there is a question here. My question is:

  • Given all of the above, why do American Christians cling blindly to Capitalism as the ultimate liberator?

Jeffrey

  { Why do Christians favor Capitalism as the liberator when it appears to hinder Christ's message? }

Mike replied:

Hi, Jeff —

The focus of the work we do on AskACatholic is to clarify Church teachings for confused Catholics and sincere seeking Protestants on an array of Church teachings, nevertheless, I'll give you my personal opinion on your question.

First, Popes in the past have warned about the extremes of a Capitalism form of government.
I wouldn't deny that.

Read what Pope Leo XIII and Pope St. Paul II had to say on the issue:

What Capitalism offers that other forms of government don't are:

  • freedom of speech within civil guidelines
  • freedom to worship in a manner that respects the free will of individuals in society and within their own faith
  • and mainly, under proper presidential leadership: encouragement to want to:
    • work hard
    • learn more
    • advance in ones trade
    • get involved in other community events, and
    • help ones fellow man

The one thing all these things have in common is freedom and an encouragement to want to work. Communism does not allow any freedoms, especially of worship.

Socialism discourages work and encourages government hand-outs and laziness.

Sound familiar?
<Can you spell: O — B — A — M — A > or,
<Can you spell: D — E — M —O— C — R — A — T — S >

As a cashier, I witness so many new people who have come into our country who are visibly able to work, yet are receiving SNAP or food assistance cards, paid through the taxes I have paid.

The President has done his part; my local government in Massachusetts now has to do its part.

You said:
My problem with Capitalism is the focus is upon consumerism and self-interest.

That's the price you pay for living in a free society with people choosing to be selfish with their own earnings. If more American Christians lived like Christians, especially Catholic Christians, the United States of America would be a much better place.

Part of the problem is that parents don't appreciate the importance of disciplining and catechizing their children appropriately.

  • Why?

Because they were never catechized and encouraged to love and die for the faith like the Early Church Fathers did.  The other part is the trickle-down-affect poor Catholic seminary environments have, resulting in scandalous so-called catholic seminary professors teaching within our seminaries.  This is one area that the Church and bishops have to be continually vigilant in.

  • Why?

Because if satan can bring down the Catholic seminary culture, with time, he will bring down Christianity in America.

It's my prayer this last part is changing for the better. I offer further suggestions to the clerical leaders of the Catholic Church in the following posting:

You said:
I find that consumerism and self-interest are just as enslaving to the individual as any totalitarian state.

I disagree. The difference can be found in that the individual in the totalitarian country cannot change if (he|she) wanted to, because the government, as in Socialism, dictates their behavior.

In our Capitalist form of government which was founded on Judeo-Christian values, freedom comes from the people and is delegated to their representatives. Because freedom is respected:

  • yes, people can choose to be selfish and hold on to their wealth, or
  • do the Christian thing and spread the wealth to help others in the United States.

. . . and they can freely change their mind any time and go from being the biggest sinner in America to the holiest saint in America.

Just my opinion.

Mike

Please report any and all typos or grammatical errors.
Suggestions for this web page and the web site can be sent to Mike Humphrey
© 2012 Panoramic Sites
The Early Church Fathers Church Fathers on the Primacy of Peter. The Early Church Fathers on the Catholic Church and the term Catholic. The Early Church Fathers on the importance of the Roman Catholic Church centered in Rome.