Hi, guys —

I've been dialoguing with a Catholic who has dissented from the Church by breaking off to the right. She is a member of the third order of the Society of St. Pius X, a schismatic society.

I've taken the long dialogue I had with her and I have pulled out the major arguments she had.
It comes with the usual dissenting non-Catholic opinions:

1. Vatican II was merely a Pastoral Council with the exception of Lumen Gentium, which restated the things already stated in previous Councils.
2. The Vatican II documents were hijacked from the bishops with the Petri.
3. The Masons and communists subverted Vatican II.
4. The bishops have made the Catholic Church bow down to the Protestants.
5. Pope Paul VI did not have a right to create a new Mass, therefore I cannot accept that the Novus Ordo is a valid Mass. It is so similar to a Protestant service.
6. John Paul II, although we prayed for him unceasingly, was a globalist, and he could not make one decision to stop any of the abuse that occurred on his watch, like:
   • the Assisi mess (with an earthquake occurring right afterward)
   • kissing the Koran
   • meeting with the Jews, etc.
7. This piece of junk you call a Catechism of the Catholic Church is full of flaws.

She also went on to say when Pope John XXIII and Pope Paul VI were dying, they admitted that they messed up and asked:

• Why did Pope Paul VI say that the "Smoke of Satan has entered the Church." if he was so sure he was correct in changing the Mass?

She also stated:

• Have you read the book by Cardinal Ottaviani regarding the Novus Ordo that was presented to Paul VI?
  
  — There were serious errors in the Novus Ordo that still exist today.

I've never read the Ottaviani Intervention and would like an opinion on it.

Mike